BILL NO A05407
SAME AS SAME AS S05971
SPONSOR Paulin (MS)
COSPNSR Aubry, Englebright
MLTSPNSR Buchwald, Cook, Hikind
Add S352, Ag & Mkts L
Restricts the use of exotic and wild animals in traveling circuses and shows;
prohibits the use of any wild or exotic animal that was traveling in a mobile
housing facility thirty days before the circus or show; establishes civil
penalties for violations.
NEW YORK STATE ASSEMBLY MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF LEGISLATION submitted in accordance with Assembly Rule III, Sec 1(f)
BILL NUMBER: A5407
SPONSOR: Paulin (MS)
TITLE OF BILL: An act to amend the agriculture and markets law, in
relation to restricting the use of exotic and wild animals in traveling
circuses and shows
PURPOSE OR GENERAL IDEA OF BILL:
To prohibit the use of exotic and non-domesticated animals in traveling
circuses and exhibitions
SUMMARY OF SPECIFIC PROVISIONS:
Section one provides that this act shall be known as the "traveling
exotic and wild animal protection act."
Section two provides the legislative findings.
Paragraph one of section three amends the agriculture and markets law by
adding a new section 352 to prohibit traveling circuses and shows from
displaying exotic or wild animals, including non-humane primates. Para-
graph two provides that the restriction shall not apply to exotic or
wild animals in an exhibition at a non-mobile, permanent institution or
facility, including an accredited zoo or aquarium; as part of an out
outreach program for education or conservation purposes, by a universi-
ty, college, laboratory, or other registered research facilities; in
film, television, or advertising if such use does not involve a live
public exhibition; or in a rodeo. Paragraph three provides the penalties
for violators of the act. Paragraph four lists exemptions of the act.
Paragraph five lists definitions.
Section four provides the effective date.
Traveling circuses and shows have acute negative effects on the psycho-
logical and physical health of the performing animals. The methods of
transporting, training, and maintaining these animals are often cruel
and inhumane. They are corralled and forced to perform unnatural tasks
for the sake of entertainment, while being restricted from exhibiting
natural behaviors. Due to their natural wild instincts and the immense
amount of stress placed upon the long-range animals especially, rebel-
lious actions often occur, which lead to an increased risk of public
safety. Traveling circuses and exhibitions bring the public dangerously
close to unpredictable animals, and the temporary, collapsible facili-
ties provide ix)adequ.ate protection. The mobile nature of these shows
makes it difficult for law enforcement to supervise animal treatment.
There are many alternative animal-free circuses and shows that provide
enjoyable human performance focused entetiaimnent for the public.
PRIOR LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:;
This is a new bill.
None to the state.
This act shall take effect one year after it shall have become a law.
STATE OF NEW YORK
2013-2014 Regular Sessions
February 25, 2013
Introduced by M. of A. PAULIN, AUBRY -- Multi-Sponsored by -- M. of A.
COOK, HIKIND -- read once and referred to the Committee on Agriculture
AN ACT to amend the agriculture and markets law, in relation to
restricting the use of exotic and wild animals in traveling circuses
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assem-bly, do enact as follows:
1 Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "traveling
2 exotic and wild animal protection act".
3 § 2. Legislative findings. The legislature finds that:
4 1. traveling circuses and shows are detrimental to animal welfare due
5 to the adverse effects of captivity and transport;
6 2. severe confinement, lack of free exercise, and the restriction of
7 natural behaviors, cause animals used in traveling circuses and shows to
8 suffer and be prone to health, behavioral, and psychological problems;
9 3. tricks that exotic and non-domesticated animals are forced to
10 perform require extreme physical coercion techniques, including the
11 restriction of food, the use of elephant hooks (objects used to control
12 and punish elephants), electric shocks, metal bars, whips, and other
13 forms of physical abuse;
14 4. welfare of animals subject to the conditions in traveling circuses
15 and shows, such as constant travel, limited facilities, long periods of
16 restricted movement, stress, and physical coercion, will inevitably be
17 compromised, which can lead to increased risks to public safety;
18 5. animals in traveling circuses and shows pose an additional risk to
19 public safety because such animals have wild instincts and needs and
20 have demonstrated unpredictability;
21 6. use of collapsible, temporary facilities in traveling circuses and
22 shows increases the risk of escaping exotic and non-domesticated animals
23 seriously harming workers and the public;
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
 is old law to be omitted.
A. 5407 2
1 7. traveling circuses and shows bring people dangerously close to
2 exotic and non-domesticated animals by displaying animals in inappropri-
3 ate, uncontrolled areas that are not suited for the exhibition of such
5 8. it is not possible to provide exotic and non-domesticated animals
6 with facilities sufficient to maintain the optimum physical and mental
7 health of the animals because of the suffering caused to the animals by
8 the nature of traveling circuses and shows, in which restriction of
9 movement, separation from natural groupings, restriction of food and
10 water, and physical abuse are prevalent;
11 9. due to the mobile and transitory nature of traveling circuses and
12 shows, law enforcement authorities cannot properly monitor the condi-
13 tions of the animals or follow up on previous infractions by traveling
15 10. restricting the use of exotic and non-domesticated animals in
16 traveling circuses and shows is the most cost-effective and efficient
17 way to safeguard both animal welfare and public safety; and
18 11. animal-free circuses like Cirque du Soleil are growing in number,
19 economic impact, and popularity, a testament to an educated public's
20 desire to see humane entertainment.
21 § 3. The agriculture and markets law is amended by adding a new
22 section 352 to read as follows:
23 § 352. Use of exotic or wild animals in traveling circuses and exhibi-
24 tions. 1. No traveling circus or show may allow for the participation
25 of an exotic or wild animal, including a non-human primate, in an animal
26 act if, during the thirty day period preceding such participation, such
27 animal was traveling in a mobile housing facility.
28 2. The restriction under subdivision one of this section shall not
29 apply to the use of an exotic or wild animal, including a non-human
31 (a) In an exhibition at a non-mobile, permanent institution or facili-
32 ty, including an accredited zoo or aquarium;
33 (b) As part of an outreach program for education or conservation
34 purposes by an accredited zoo, aquarium, or not-for-profit conservation
35 organization if the animal used for such purposes is not kept in a
36 mobile housing facility for more than twelve hours a day;
37 (c) By a university, college, laboratory, or other research facility
38 registered with the secretary of the department of agriculture pursuant
39 to the Animal Welfare Act (7 U.S.C. Section 2136);
40 (d) In film, television, or advertising if such use does not involve a
41 live public exhibition; or
42 (e) In a rodeo.
43 3. A traveling circus or show that fails to comply with this section
44 or any rule, regulation, or standard promulgated by the commissioner
45 thereunder, may be assessed a civil penalty by the commissioner of not
46 more than ten thousand dollars for each such violation, and the commis-
47 sioner may also make an order that such person shall cease and desist
48 from continuing such violation. Each violation and each day during
49 which a violation continues shall be a separate offense. Any person who
50 knowingly fails to obey a cease and desist order made by the commission-
51 er under this section shall be subject to a civil penalty of one thou-
52 sand five hundred dollars for each offense, and each day during which
53 such failure continues shall be deemed a separate offense.
54 4. The following are exempt from the provisions of this section:
55 (a) Institutions accredited by the American Zoo and Aquarium Associ-
A. 5407 3
1 (b) Any wildlife sanctuary as defined in this section.
2 (c) Not-for-profit environmental education programs as defined under
3 this section.
4 5. For purposes of this section, the following terms shall have the
5 following meanings:
6 (a) "Traveling circus" means a class C licensee that is licensed under
7 the Animal Welfare Act (7 U.S.C. Section 2131 et seq.) and its subse-
8 quent amendments, regulations, and standards adopted pursuant to the
9 Animal Welfare Act, that offers performances by live animals, clowns,
10 and/or acrobats that travel in mobile housing facilities.
11 (b) "Show" means any mobile or stationary act, circus, public show,
12 trade show, photographic opportunity, carnival, city or county fair,
13 agricultural fair, ride, parade, race, performance, or similar undertak-
14 ing incorporating wild or exotic animals wherein the animals are taken
15 from their permanent residence and required to travel for any distance.
16 (c) "Person" means an individual, partnership, corporation, joint
17 venture, association, trust, estate, or any other legal entity, and any
18 officer, member, shareholder, director, employee, agent, or represen-
19 tative of these.
20 (d) "Exotic or wild animals" means any or all of the following or the
21 following orders and families, whether born in the wild or in captivity,
22 and also any or all of their hybrids with domestic species. The animals
23 listed are intended to act as examples and are not to be construed as an
24 exhaustive list or limit the generality of each group of animals, unless
25 otherwise specified:
26 (i) Non-human primates and prosimians, such as chimpanzees, baboons
27 and monkeys;
28 (ii) Felidae, such as lions, tigers, cougars, leopards, ocelots and
29 servals, but shall not include domesticated animals;
30 (iii) Canidae, such as wolves and coyotes, but shall not include
31 domestic dogs;
32 (iv) Ursidae, such as bears;
33 (v) Marsupialia, such as kangaroos;
34 (vi) Proboscidae, such as elephants;
35 (vii) Artiodactyla, such as giraffes and camels, but shall not include
36 domestic cattle, swine, sheep, or goats;
37 (viii) Perissodactyla, such as zebras, but shall not include domestic
38 horses, donkeys, or mules.
39 (e) "Wildlife sanctuary" means a 501(c)(3) organization described in
40 section 170(b)(1)(A)(vi) of the Internal Revenue Code 1986, and its
41 subsequent amendments where:
42 (i) No commercial trade in animals occurs, including, but not limited
43 to, sale of animals, animal parts, by-products, offspring, photographic
44 opportunities or public events for financial profit, or any other enter-
45 tainment purposes;
46 (ii) No propagation of animals occurs in the facility; and
47 (iii) No escorted public visitation is allowed; no direct contact
48 between the public and wild animals is allowed; animals are not taken
49 from the sanctuary or enclosures for exhibition.
50 (f) "Domesticated animal" means any domesticated sheep, horse, cattle,
51 fallow deer, red deer, sika deer, whitetail deer which is raised under
52 license from the department of environmental conservation, llama, goat,
53 swine, fowl, duck, goose, swan, turkey, confined domestic hare or
54 rabbit, pheasant or other bird which is raised in confinement under
55 license from the department of environmental conservation before release
56 from captivity, except that the varieties of fowl commonly used for cock
A. 5407 4
1 fights shall not be considered domestic animals for the purposes of this
3 (g) "Environmental education program" means animal use or exhibition
4 that is devoted to imparting knowledge or information about the exhib-
5 ited animal's behavior, habitat, life cycle, migratory patterns, feeding
6 habits or similar pedagogical information and is conducted by an indi-
7 vidual or individuals who is/are accredited or similarly qualified to
8 impart such information. At no time during an educational exhibition
9 will any animal be made to perform any behavior that is not intrin-
10 sically natural to the animal.
11 § 4. This act shall take effect one year after it shall have become a
12 law. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any
13 rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its
14 effective date is authorized to be made on or before such date.