Outline of New York State & the NYS Assembly Seal

New York State Assembly

Speaker Carl E. Heastie
  -  This bill is not active in this session.
 

S04641 Summary:

BILL NOS04641
 
SAME ASSAME AS A04236
 
SPONSORPERSAUD
 
COSPNSRKAPLAN
 
MLTSPNSR
 
Amd §332-b, Soc Serv L
 
Establishes factors and requirements to be considered when a health care practitioner's opinion differs from that of an applicant's treating health care practitioner's opinion as to an applicant's disability.
Go to top    

S04641 Actions:

BILL NOS04641
 
03/19/2019REFERRED TO SOCIAL SERVICES
04/09/20191ST REPORT CAL.440
04/10/20192ND REPORT CAL.
04/29/2019ADVANCED TO THIRD READING
05/07/2019PASSED SENATE
05/07/2019DELIVERED TO ASSEMBLY
05/07/2019referred to social services
05/29/2019substituted for a4236
05/29/2019ordered to third reading cal.115
05/29/2019passed assembly
05/29/2019returned to senate
11/26/2019DELIVERED TO GOVERNOR
12/06/2019VETOED MEMO.179
Go to top

S04641 Committee Votes:

Go to top
S04641 Floor Votes:
DATE:05/29/2019Assembly Vote                            YEA/NAY: 107/34
Yes      
Abbate 
Yes      
Crespo 
ER      
Gantt 
No      
LiPetri 
Yes      
Perry 
Yes      
Simon 
Yes      
Abinanti 
No      
Crouch 
No      
Garbarino 
Yes      
Lupardo 
Yes      
Pheffer Amato 
Yes      
Simotas 
Yes      
Arroyo 
Yes      
Cruz 
ER      
Giglio 
Yes      
Magnarelli 
ER      
Pichardo 
No      
Smith 
Yes      
Ashby 
Yes      
Cusick 
Yes      
Glick 
Yes      
Malliotakis 
Yes      
Pretlow 
No      
Smullen 
Yes      
Aubry 
Yes      
Cymbrowitz 
No      
Goodell 
No      
Manktelow 
No      
Quart 
Yes      
Solages 
No      
Barclay 
Yes      
Davila 
Yes      
Gottfried 
Yes      
McDonald 
No      
Ra 
No      
Stec 
Yes      
Barnwell 
Yes      
De La Rosa 
Yes      
Griffin 
ER      
McDonough 
Yes      
Raia 
Yes      
Steck 
Yes      
Barrett 
Yes      
DenDekker 
Yes      
Gunther 
Yes      
McMahon 
Yes      
Ramos 
Yes      
Stern 
Yes      
Barron 
Yes      
DeStefano 
Yes      
Hawley 
No      
Mikulin 
Yes      
Raynor 
Yes      
Stirpe 
Yes      
Benedetto 
Yes      
Dickens 
Yes      
Hevesi 
No      
Miller B   
No      
Reilly 
No      
Tague 
Yes      
Bichotte 
Yes      
Dilan 
Yes      
Hunter 
Yes      
Miller MG  
Yes      
Reyes 
Yes      
Taylor 
Yes      
Blake 
Yes      
Dinowitz 
Yes      
Hyndman 
Yes      
Miller ML  
Yes      
Richardson 
Yes      
Thiele 
No      
Blankenbush 
No      
DiPietro 
Yes      
Jacobson 
ER      
Montesano 
Yes      
Rivera 
ER      
Titus 
No      
Brabenec 
Yes      
D'Urso 
Yes      
Jaffee 
Yes      
Morinello 
Yes      
Rodriguez 
Yes      
Vanel 
No      
Braunstein 
Yes      
Eichenstein 
Yes      
Jean-Pierre 
Yes      
Mosley 
Yes      
Romeo 
No      
Walczyk 
Yes      
Bronson 
Yes      
Englebright 
No      
Johns 
Yes      
Niou 
Yes      
Rosenthal D   
Yes      
Walker 
Yes      
Buchwald 
Yes      
Epstein 
Yes      
Jones 
ER      
Nolan 
Yes      
Rosenthal L   
Yes      
Wallace 
Yes      
Burke 
Yes      
Fahy 
Yes      
Joyner 
No      
Norris 
Yes      
Rozic 
Yes      
Walsh 
Yes      
Buttenschon 
Yes      
Fall 
Yes      
Kim 
ER      
O'Donnell 
Yes      
Ryan 
Yes      
Weinstein 
No      
Byrne 
Yes      
Fernandez 
No      
Kolb 
Yes      
Ortiz 
Yes      
Salka 
Yes      
Weprin 
No      
Byrnes 
No      
Finch 
No      
Lalor 
Yes      
Otis 
Yes      
Santabarbara 
Yes      
Williams 
Yes      
Cahill 
No      
Fitzpatrick 
Yes      
Lavine 
No      
Palmesano 
Yes      
Sayegh 
No      
Woerner 
Yes      
Carroll 
No      
Friend 
No      
Lawrence 
Yes      
Palumbo 
No      
Schimminger 
Yes      
Wright 
Yes      
Colton 
Yes      
Frontus 
Yes      
Lentol 
ER      
Paulin 
No      
Schmitt 
Yes      
Zebrowski 
Yes      
Cook 
Yes      
Galef 
Yes      
Lifton 
Yes      
Peoples-Stokes 
Yes      
Seawright 
Yes      
Mr. Speaker 
 
 ‡ Indicates voting via videoconference  
Go to top
S04641 Text:



 
                STATE OF NEW YORK
        ________________________________________________________________________
 
                                          4641
 
                               2019-2020 Regular Sessions
 
                    IN SENATE
 
                                     March 19, 2019
                                       ___________
 
        Introduced  by  Sen. PERSAUD -- read twice and ordered printed, and when
          printed to be committed to the Committee on Social Services
 
        AN ACT to amend the social services law,  in  relation  to  establishing
          factors  to  be considered when a health care practitioner  upon exam-
          ination has a different opinion from an  applicant's  treating  health
          care practitioner's opinion as to an applicant's disability
 
          The  People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assem-
        bly, do enact as follows:
 
     1    Section 1. Section 332-b of the social  services  law  is  amended  by
     2  adding a new subdivision 4-b to read as follows:
     3    4-b.  In the event the practitioner to whom the individual is referred
     4  pursuant to subdivision four or paragraph (b) of subdivision two of this
     5  section issues an opinion that differs  from  the  applicant's  treating
     6  health care practitioner's opinion, the applicant's treating health care
     7  practitioner's  opinion  is  generally  controlling, subject to, but not
     8  limited to, the following factors:
     9    (a) the length and frequency of the treatment provided,
    10    (b) consistency of the opinion with the record as a whole,
    11    (c) the degree to which the opinion is supported by concrete evidence,
    12  and
    13    (d) the practitioner's specialty.
    14    § 2. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day  after  it  shall
    15  have become a law.
 
 
 
         EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
                              [ ] is old law to be omitted.
                                                                   LBD01067-01-9



Go to top